Very possibly, yes, if not probable.
When replacing parts you really should replace like-for-like, which isn’t to say that it has to be the genuine pukka item as very often there are alternatives available, same factory, different sticker on the box very often. Or, there are some which there is no difference in at all other than a terminal or whatever, but with fans and stuff, it’s best to be as close to the original as possible.
Case in point, if the replacement you’ve fitted isn’t driving enough air over the element either by air direction or volume/speed it will pop every few months.
K.