Looking for a quiet fridge freezer

Home Forums Public Support Forums Help And Support Fridge And Freezer Forum Looking for a quiet fridge freezer

Viewing 10 posts - 1 through 10 (of 10 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #39746
    Tim L
    Participant

    Last week I replaced a broken Candy frost-free model (the N1B and its seemingly endemic freezing fridge compartment) with an Indesit BAN12. Again, a frost free model, but this time of the design which circulates air in the fridge too.

    Anyway, it’s annoyingly loud when the compressor and fan kick in. I sit about eight feet away from it, and can hear it even with the kitchen door shut – it’s a low, irritating drone. An Indesit engineer has decreed it to normal, perhaps even quieter than usual, so there’s no hope there.

    Fortunately the shop I bought it from has agreed to swap it for something else, but now I’m worried that I’ll pick something just as noisy, or worse – even noisier. Until last week it hadn’t even occurred to me that noise would be an issue!

    I’m thinking that avoiding frost-free would be a good start, as that takes the fan out of the picture. What I’d like to know is which models are the quietest, either by design or reputation?

    Cheers!

    #263415
    iadom
    Moderator

    Re: Looking for a quiet fridge freezer

    Quality 😉

    #263416
    Tim L
    Participant

    Re: Looking for a quiet fridge freezer

    Are all their models very quiet then? I’ve picked out this one as being the most suitable:

    http://www.liebherr.com/hg/en/products_ … -0_18495-0

    The only thing that worries me is that the shop I’m stuck with might not be able to get hold of Liebherr stock. What else should I consider as a plan B?

    #263417
    iadom
    Moderator

    Re: Looking for a quiet fridge freezer

    Don’s the best man to advise you, he may pick up on this and give you a better answer than I can.

    Liebherr are about the best you can buy ATM.

    #263418
    don
    Moderator

    Re: Looking for a quiet fridge freezer

    Plan B would be Miele. Made by Liebherr and re badged with slightly different interior cosmetics.


    Don

    #263419
    Martin
    Participant

    Re: Looking for a quiet fridge freezer

    Tim L wrote:What I’d like to know is which models are the quietest, either by design or reputation?

    It would be interesting to know if a Liebherr is any quieter than other brands? I’m sure that quality plays a part in reducing the noise factor but I’m not convinced there’s any guarantee? They don’t state noise levels in their spec IIRC? 😕

    Could also be that in Tim L’s case the location is on a wooden floor between kitchen cabinets that act like a resonating acoustic guitar anyway. Liebherr (being German) would therefore sound like Beethoven’s Fifth Overture when its on a defrost cycle. 😈 (Only kidding but you catch my drift – don’t you? 🙂 )

    #263420
    Tim L
    Participant

    Re: Looking for a quiet fridge freezer

    Martin wrote:

    Tim L wrote:
    What I’d like to know is which models are the quietest, either by design or reputation?

    It would be interesting to know if a Liebherr is any quieter than other brands? I’m sure that quality plays a part in reducing the noise factor but I’m not convinced there’s any guarantee? They don’t state noise levels in their spec IIRC? 😕

    I’ve found noise ratings in the specs on Comet’s site, and using some Google-Fu have worked out the quietest suitable model is this at 36db:

    http://www.comet.co.uk/shopcomet/produc … L-ART477-4

    However at £480 it’s a bit more than I was planning on spending (the model I’ll be swapping with cost £300).

    Then there were a few at 38db, including the favourite so far:

    http://www.comet.co.uk/shopcomet/produc … RR-CUP3021

    I’m not sure how much I should trust these ratings though, as they also list the frost-free version of that Liebherr model as 38db, which seems fishy. They do list my current noisy fridge as 43db though, so on paper the non-frost-free Liebherr looks like a good bet.

    Could also be that in Tim L’s case the location is on a wooden floor between kitchen cabinets that act like a resonating acoustic guitar anyway. Liebherr (being German) would therefore sound like Beethoven’s Fifth Overture when its on a defrost cycle. 😈 (Only kidding but you catch my drift – don’t you? 🙂 )

    It’s actually on a concrete floor. Part of the problem is that the kitchen door is of the traditional style with thin wooden panels, so doesn’t do a great job at cutting down noise. There’s not much I can do about that – the house is rented.

    #263421
    Tim L
    Participant

    Re: Looking for a quiet fridge freezer

    don wrote:Plan B would be Miele. Made by Liebherr and re badged with slightly different interior cosmetics.


    Don

    Good lord, they’re expensive! 😯

    #263422
    kwatt
    Keymaster

    Re: Looking for a quiet fridge freezer

    They’re also very good. 😉

    On noise, have a read at this article as it may shed some light.

    K.

    #263423
    Tim L
    Participant

    Re: Looking for a quiet fridge freezer

    kwatt wrote:They’re also very good. 😉

    On noise, have a read at this article as it may shed some light.

    K.

    Heh – I did wonder how reliable those ratings were.

Viewing 10 posts - 1 through 10 (of 10 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.