Home › Forums › General Trade Forum › FLOOR DISCLAIMER
- This topic has 8 replies, 7 voices, and was last updated 16 years, 3 months ago by
funkyboogy.
-
AuthorPosts
-
January 9, 2010 at 10:19 am #51499
funkyboogy
Participanthas anyone got an example of a floor disclaimer ,
i read a few post where it was mentioned that they are not worth the paper they are written on , but surley they must have some relevance..
cheers ally..ps if you have one can you email it to me …admin@atsscotland.co.uk
January 10, 2010 at 8:33 am #308296expertcat
ParticipantWhen I worked for my last company we used to fill out a floor disclimer.
Even though it was company policy it apparently was just a waste of paper and ink.
I still had to go around and due door floor damage inspections that my engineers had done.January 10, 2010 at 10:39 am #308297squadman
ParticipantRe: FLOOR DISCLAIMER
Disclaimers of this nature will as far as I am aware not protect you or your servants in the event of a claim of damage. You often see such disclaimers to the effect that ” we shall not be responsible for any damage or claim however caused ” which means that should we wreck your house in the course of our business you will not have a leg to stand on ! I am no legal expert Jackel will know the specifics of this type of cluase but whenever you provide a service you have a duty of care which does have legal standing and should you damage someones property in the course of your business then I would say that the client would have success in getting you to make good that damage, that is why PLI is required as if we could merely get clients to sign away their rights we would not need the expense of PLI
that’s why even if a company has such a disclaimer they still have a inspection to see if there servant was responsible and to protect themselves should litigation take place as a result. I can remember once when I had a car damaged at a supermarket by a car cleaning company who washed the car in error resulting in multiple damage to the vehicle and they had a lengthy disclaimer which they thought would let them off the hook. After three years of legal wranglings they would not deal correctly with the matter and they engaged a top law firm to get rid of me. I took them to court and the court found in my favour and the disclaimer was ignored in court and the judge found that even though we had not entered into a contract with this company and they cleaned the car in error they had a duty of care which they failed to follow and we were awarded damages and full costs !
When moving appliances on flooring that is easily damaged it pays to have a square of hardboard to which place the appliance onJanuary 10, 2010 at 1:15 pm #308298bagman
ParticipantRe: FLOOR DISCLAIMER
After years of experience, I find that if it looks likely that moving a machine will cause damage, I ask the customer to move it. If they cannot (too old or infirm) then I ask that they arrange to have it moved.
I’ve never had one refuse so far, and if they did I’d just walk away. Life’s too short to get bogged down in other peoples problems.January 10, 2010 at 6:52 pm #308299lee8
ParticipantRe: FLOOR DISCLAIMER
Ditto that.
The money you make will not cover the damage you may cause, so don’t bother.
In my experience of Engineers the ones who cause the damage are usually the engineers who don’t know when to give up and will need to be dragged away kickin and screaming rather than admit defeat. 😆
A friendof mine spent nearly 15 hrs on an appliance he’d picked up from a client, he admitted he was just curious as it was an unusual fault.
In the end he only charged £30 or 50 pence and hr rather than take my advice at the beginning and right it off. :rolls:
January 11, 2010 at 5:58 pm #308300funkyboogy
ParticipantRe: FLOOR DISCLAIMER
yeh tend to agree with all comments ,
we are currently involved in high volumes of american f/f removal for a large korean co , and as a result we are coming across lots of potential floor issues .. most customer are great and some will also have f/f removed but we have had a few where we have walked away due to nice hardwood floors…etc.i thought we could have something in place like a disclaimer that goes something like …. although our engineer will take all reasonable precautions whilst removing your appliance their may be a chance of damage to flooring due to
1 debris/grit trapped under the rear wheels etc
2 the phyiscal size and weight of appliance
3 can think of something just now …what im trying to say is that surley if you take all reasonable precaution and customer has agreed to you removing appliance then surley if matter goes to court etc you can at least demonstrate that all reasonable methods were used to prevent damage ..
January 11, 2010 at 7:49 pm #308301kwatt
KeymasterRe: FLOOR DISCLAIMER
Do a search on here for “Airsled”. 😉
TBH I was told a long time ago the any disclaimer of that nature was a waste of space as, if you take on the job you’ve formed a contract to fix it and when you attempt to remove and cause damage in the course of doing that, you’re liable. End of story.
The biggest reason that disclaimers don’t stand up is that they open the doors for traders to do whatever they like with no recrimination, therefore courts tend to totally ignore them.
Now, you get into the murky waters…
If you explain to the homeowner the potential for damage and ask them if they want you to proceed then they have a degree of responsibility as well. But, in reality, most people are reasonable on this when it’s explained.
Just take a note on the job sheet that you have advised, ask the customer to sign that you have advised them of the potential for damage and you’re as safe as you can be.
Or you go the hard line way and, if you are in any doubt whatsoever I’d advise this, you walk away saying that the risk of damage is too great. In short, you’ve assessed the risk to the home that may be caused by removal and it is too great.
In all honesty, most times especially on warranty and insurance calls this is the only way as otherwise you will almost certainly get a claim for the damage. The reason being that the customer just assumes you’re part of a big company, whatever company you happen to be contracted to, and they think it’s coming out their pocket, not yours.
The manufacturer/insurer/WP meanwhile simply says that it’s your problem, you did it. I have been continually astounded by many on this front as you get no back up when it does go wrong like that and very little backup when you refuse to remove it.
You just can’t win. So, doesn’t matter what you do, someone’s (or some parties) aren’t going to be happy campers and that’ll be that.
The only thing I’d recommend is do unto others and make sure it’s not you that ends up out of pocket over it as the grief from letters of complaint, stupid claims and paying insurance excesses and policy increases are simply not worth the aggravation, time or cost.
K.
January 13, 2010 at 7:19 pm #308302Jonah
ParticipantRe: FLOOR DISCLAIMER
Had this exact problem yesterday, not flooring but worktop problem, very expensive kitchen with a De Dietrich Induction Hob fitted extemely tight into worktop also siliconed/grip filled in by kitchen fitter (well builder who thinks he can fit kitchens !!) can’t remove hob as it’s solid, after nearly 30 years of working on built in appliances I know when to walk away.
Customer was understanding as she could see that serious damage could be caused to both hob and worktop, I walked away after advising her to get a proper kitchen fitter out not the builder to try and get it out then I would come back and repair it, needless to say she called said builder to complain about the way he fitted and he said ‘engineers know naff all about kitchens I’ll get it out’.
The customer phones me in the evening in tears as he’s broken the glass on the hob and knackered her worktop levering it out, she is now going to claim on his PL insurance, what a numpty 😯
January 13, 2010 at 8:02 pm #308303lee8
ParticipantRe: FLOOR DISCLAIMER
Kitchen fitters I have come across are not exactly bright.
I had a cooker hood yesterday, could not see the securing screws at the top of the chimney, as they where obscured by the coving around the ceiling.
After I explained to client she rung the fitter.
He explained to me that the bracket that screws to wall was placed on the ceiling, the bottom section needs to be removed and an arm with a long screw driver needs to be sent through the 2 inch gap up to the ceiling.
He stated it was a pig to install.
I stated it’ll be a pig for you too remove then and the client will need to pay us a callout charge for the wasted visit as the installation instructions were not followed and impossible to remove appliance covers to access the motor securing screws.
He argued that the design was crap as most ceilings have a coving, to which I explained most competent fitters would have placed the bracket on the wall lower than the coving and drilled two holes through the chimney allowing the screws to secure to the bracket and allow a quick and painless removal. :rolls:
Now I’m afraid the removal and reinstallation is your responsibility and I suggest you reinstall properly.
Client has paid us and is looking to claim from him the charge and we are returning next week. 😆
-
AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
