Home › Forums › Public Support Forums › Help And Support › Washing Machine Help Forum › ISE10 1607W or Mele 3204, Bosch or Zanussi
- This topic has 12 replies, 7 voices, and was last updated 15 years, 5 months ago by
mwilliams.
-
AuthorPosts
-
October 19, 2010 at 3:12 pm #58119
mwilliams
ParticipantHi,
I’m seriously considering replacing our dying (worn bearings) Zanussi with the new ISE10 1607 machine. However, I note that it will have a bigger drum (8kg) than the outgoing model and a spin of 1600rpm.
Having seen the buying help advice offered on the UKWhitegoods website re washing machine loads and spin speeds I’m concerned that the new model might not be a good idea for our simple needs: average of 3 to 4 washes per week with no-one having sensitive skin.
In particular your advice on load sizes says:
“where a capacity over 5Kg was used that the mechanical action of the machine was affected. You can get over this problem with some clever drum design to take it to a 6Kg load and retain the wash results but, beyond that it becomes very difficult.”
and
“The other gem of information that isn’t told to people is that these machines require more water and more electricity for EVERY wash. For example a typical 7Kg load machine will use 15{e5d1b7155a01ef1f3b9c9968eaba33524ee81600d00d4be2b4d93ac2e58cec2d} more electricity and up to 10{e5d1b7155a01ef1f3b9c9968eaba33524ee81600d00d4be2b4d93ac2e58cec2d} more water than a standard 6Kg load machine but, because of the way the EU labeling system works it can still be sold as an “A” rated machine. Over a year this can add up to an additional 1800 litres of water, up to £73 a year in electricity and upwards of £30 a year on detergent.”And on speed spins your advice says:
“the difference between 800rpm and 1000 or 1100rpm was literally a thimble full of water”
and
“the bearings in the machine are also under far more strain the faster the drum spins so they tend to wear out quicker” and “the harder the spin the more potential wear on the clothing as well”.So I could do with some advice on whether the ISE10 1607 is good for our needs or whether we should buy a cheaper machine with a 6kg drum and spin of 1200 or 1300 rpm, e.g. a Miele W3204 for £699 or a Bosch or Zanussi?
Many thanks
October 19, 2010 at 3:23 pm #333437timdowning
ParticipantRe: ISE10 1607W or Mele 3204, Bosch or Zanussi
As a starting point could you give us the product number from your Zanussi. This will allow comparisons to be made to what new machine will be best for you.
The product number is on a sticker inside the door. starts with a 9.
Thanks.
October 19, 2010 at 4:29 pm #333438mwilliams
ParticipantRe: ISE10 1607W or Mele 3204, Bosch or Zanussi
The dying Zanussi is a ZWF1217W model number 91451770000
October 19, 2010 at 6:10 pm #333439timdowning
ParticipantRe: ISE10 1607W or Mele 3204, Bosch or Zanussi
for our simple needs
Your machine is 1200 spin with a 6kg load. Its not to older model & your bearings are failing already with low usage. So theres an answer there for you.
Theres no right or wrong. How much do you want to spend, will you use the larger capacity drum, would you like a faster spin???
The bearings in the ISE are far superior to your Zanussi plus you can always fall back on the 10 years guarantee so I wouldn’t worry on that account.
If you were to tumble dry 1200 spun items compared to 1600 spun there is a saving which will counteract the other costs you listed.
October 20, 2010 at 7:44 am #333440mwilliams
ParticipantRe: ISE10 1607W or Mele 3204, Bosch or Zanussi
Hi and thanks for your comments.
I’ve checked our current Zanussi and it says on the front of it that it is a 5kg hydrowash which I assume means that the drum has a 5kg capacity.
What concerns me about the new ISE10 1607 is that it is an 8kg drum capacity with a 1600rpm spin, which both seem to be much greater capacities than what is recommended to buy on this website’s buying advice pages (as per my first post).
This sites recommendations seem to imply that we anything over a 5kg or 6kg machine affects the machine’s mechanical action and that anything with a spin over 1200 rpm has very little effect on extracting more water from the washing.
Hence, if I follow this sites advice I should confine myself to a 6kg machine with a 1200 or 1300 rpm maximum spin. However, it seems the ISE10 is better built but does it overcome the problems caused by having a larger drum?
October 20, 2010 at 9:52 am #333441odom
ParticipantRe: ISE10 1607W or Mele 3204, Bosch or Zanussi
Ken, who specced the machine, will probably give you a better answer, but there’s two primary differences between an 8kg ISE10 and an 8kg domestic machine, e.g. Hotpoint or similar: –
– With Hotpoints, if you buy an 8kg machine you simply buy a larger drum. All the components, e.g. suspension, bearings, remain exactly the same – basically, as cheaply engineered as possible whilst still doing the job. This means that they almost inevitably fail pretty quickly. The ISE10 is a “semi-commercial” machine, with engineering to match. This means the beefed up suspension and bearings are over-engineered to handle the extra capacity and higher spin speed.
– Likewise, unlike some cheap domestic 8kg machine, where the drum is just a “stretched” 6kg design, the ISE10 has a specially designed drum which gently pushes the washing into the centre of the drum whilst agitating it, making for a better wash. The new ISE10 is meant to be even better than Miele’s “Honeycomb” drum because it has special traps allowing grit & grass to escape, which is the common complaint about Miele’s drums. Quite simply – a lot of thought has gone into the design because in the end you’ll be using this for 20+ years so it’s important that it washes properly.
Having said all that, a 8kg drum only makes sense if you are going to use the extra capacity. If you find your current machine more than ample capacity wise, then stick with that.
October 20, 2010 at 1:13 pm #333442kwatt
KeymasterRe: ISE10 1607W or Mele 3204, Bosch or Zanussi
Hi,
First off, the 8kg thing on most washers is a tad misleading. What you are better looking at (where anyone will actually tell you) is the actual drum capacity in litres. The 1607 has a drum capacity (true) of 60 litres.
Without going into huge detail, you will find that the rating in kg is often used but there is no detail to back up the figure and there is no requirement for it to be proved either, it can just be a claimed figure. It can also take into account the recess for the door bowl for example under test, which obviously can’t be used in reality.
There’s all sorts of marketing games go on, the trick is seeing through a lot of them. 😉
The 1607 (and all the new platform machines) can spin at the speed with stability as, quite simply, it’s built properly and due to that, the suspension can soak up the vibration whilst the cabinet is rigid enough to support the high speed spins. The drum and cabinet can actually handle quite easily a 2000rpm spin speed. They’re in some ways over-engineered in terms of quality.
As a comparison, the same drum will extract 47{e5d1b7155a01ef1f3b9c9968eaba33524ee81600d00d4be2b4d93ac2e58cec2d} of water at 1400rpm, 56{e5d1b7155a01ef1f3b9c9968eaba33524ee81600d00d4be2b4d93ac2e58cec2d} at 1600rpm and 57{e5d1b7155a01ef1f3b9c9968eaba33524ee81600d00d4be2b4d93ac2e58cec2d} at 1800rpm. As you can see it’s a law of diminishing returns but 1600rpm is about the best balance in terms of cost to efficiency in the ISE machine.
The 1607 exerts a G-factor that is, I am told, the highest in the industry compared with any machine of a similar spin speed, basically, more efficient.
What water extraction rates are for other machines I often don’t know as most manufacturer’s are reluctant to publish the figures as it means that they can be accurately compared with others.
What the active drum does is get around the traditional downsides with large capacity machines as odom rightly points out, by gently moving the clothes to the centre of the drum. No other machine does this.
I hope that answers what you’re asking but, if not feel free to ask.
K.
October 20, 2010 at 4:39 pm #333443mwilliams
ParticipantRe: ISE10 1607W or Mele 3204, Bosch or Zanussi
Thanks Ken, Chris and Tim for your help.
I’ve decided to go for the 1607. Ken, I understand that it is not likely to be available until sometime in November but has the date been firmed up yet?
Cheers,
MarkOctober 20, 2010 at 6:53 pm #333444quickwash
ParticipantRe: ISE10 1607W or Mele 3204, Bosch or Zanussi
hi, i read on her somewhere that it was the 5th of november. Also as per your first post i think i am right in saying that the 1607 has a smart fill for water and electricity 🙂 Definately think you have made the right choice, i am also having the 1607 as it built like a tank and has the 10 year guarantee, i dont know if you have already read up on the machine but another plus is that if required parts are cheaper after the machine is out of guarantee :tup:
October 20, 2010 at 9:46 pm #333445kwatt
KeymasterRe: ISE10 1607W or Mele 3204, Bosch or Zanussi
Hi Mark,
The machines should be in our warehouse week commencing 9th November, we hope they will be there on the 5th but I can’t 100{e5d1b7155a01ef1f3b9c9968eaba33524ee81600d00d4be2b4d93ac2e58cec2d} guarantee it right now. As soon as we have a definitive date we won’t hesitate in letting everyone know.
Any pre-ordered machines will take priority and be basically dispatched as soon as is humanly possible, in other words, as soon as they go live on the stock system. We’re having to do this as there’s a few people been waiting for the new machine for a number of weeks now but all the pre-orders we have will be fulfilled as things stand right now with stock in hand as we’ve managed to persuade/coerce/beg the factory to make more than we originally had planned at that point.
We’ve actually been beavering away in the background trying to arrange a special overland run to get them here sooner but we don’t know how that’s going to go just yet.
The problem with the sea option is the run from Sweden takes the boats to Iceland then down to the UK (I don’t get it either) which can cause issues on shipping times, so we’re trying to insure against that basically.
It does all come down to shipping.
You’d think that it was an easy thing to sort out but there you go.
I spoke to the factory today and everything from that end is tickety boo and on schedule. So, we know that the machines will be ready 100{e5d1b7155a01ef1f3b9c9968eaba33524ee81600d00d4be2b4d93ac2e58cec2d} for sure.
In short, the delivery date can move a few days here of there but it shouldn’t be by too much. What I don’t want to do is promise an absolute date then it doesn’t happen bang on because the French blockade the channel in protest, Iceland freezes over or blows up and so on. 😉
quickwash, yes the machine does indeed have a smart fill, it only uses the water that it has to so it automatically determines a small or large load or anything in between and adjusts and compensates as it operates. This in turn, because you only use what you need, means that you reduce the electricity requirement as, by a huge margin, the electricity used heating water is the single largest use of power. But from a use point of view it’s dead simple… put in laundry, add detergent, select program (if it isn’t the same as the last one you did, if it is the same, skip “select program”), close door, press start… done.
The idea is to make what really is a dull chore as efficient, simple and hassle free as is humanly possible. For a long time.
HTH
K.
October 21, 2010 at 10:17 am #333446dmajohnson
ParticipantRe: ISE10 1607W or Mele 3204, Bosch or Zanussi
For what it’s worth Meile are currently offering free upgrades to a 10yr warranty by redemption on some models.
I’m currently in the same situation, trying to decide between an ISE10 or a Meile. Trouble is my machine is bust and I’m bagging up my washing and have family doing it for me. I don’t know if I can hold out till Nov 5th :(.
October 21, 2010 at 10:40 am #333447mwilliams
ParticipantRe: ISE10 1607W or Mele 3204, Bosch or Zanussi
Many thanks. I’ve now pre-ordered an ISE10 1607 through my local supplier.
Mark
October 25, 2010 at 12:21 pm #333448Savlona
ParticipantRe: ISE10 1607W or Mele 3204, Bosch or Zanussi
dmajohnson wrote:For what it’s worth Meile are currently offering free upgrades to a 10yr warranty by redemption on some models.
I’m currently in the same situation, trying to decide between an ISE10 or a Meile. Trouble is my machine is bust and I’m bagging up my washing and have family doing it for me. I don’t know if I can hold out till Nov 5th :(.
I’m holding out -the local laundrette has been a godsend – turn up on a Sunday morning with the family wash, load up a few machines and I’m out in less than an hour. Will be glad when my machine arrives though 😆 -
AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
