Pat test failed,What mega reading do i need

Home Forums Trade Technical & Spare Parts Forums Trade Technical Enquiries Pat test failed,What mega reading do i need

  • This topic has 11 replies, 8 voices, and was last updated 15 years ago by pmb.
Viewing 12 posts - 1 through 12 (of 12 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #61966
    pmb
    Participant

    Letting agent has asked me to look at a washing machine and dryer at the same property, Both failed PAT test,
    Whats the minimum I need to get on the mega, Is it 2 meg now.
    Is their an easy way to to neutralize carbon dust in motor,
    Somebody was spraying something in motor but i cannot remember what.

    #348182
    Martin
    Participant

    Re: Pat test failed,What mega reading do i need

    10megohm should pass. WD40 or electrosolvent will clean motors nicely. Also a paintbrush will brush away carbon dust from brush rings and terminal blocks.

    #348183
    keithwilliams
    Participant

    Re: Pat test failed,What mega reading do i need

    a class 1 static appliance(heavier than 18kg)is normally tested at 1Meg. if its reading less than that then you can sometimes bring the reading back up by running it for a while,(admittedly moreso on cookers/ovens) then retest.
    however to confuse matters further our tutor on city and guilds course said that you can pass a static appliance at 0.3meg if it has a heater in it.

    #348184
    eastlmark
    Moderator

    Re: Pat test failed,What mega reading do i need

    Yes, must admit my training was some time ago but, unless its changed, 0.5 meg or above is fine for a used appliance (it needs to be far higher at factory gate).
    Why the regs are so unclear is because it is really down to the testers expereince to decide and make the decision. Which is a bit daft considering most testing is done not by us, engineers, but dedicated testers who probably dont know the product they are testing well enough to make a decision, hence a high fail rate and its not a job I would want to do.
    lets face it, just about every cooker would fail the 2 meg test and as for 10 meg……..dream on.

    #348185
    Hollytree_Technical
    Participant

    Re: Pat test failed,What mega reading do i need

    Just pulled the “Code of Practice for In-Service Inspection and Testing of Electrical Equipment – 3rd edition” off the shelf to check what it says and help to clear up any confusion.
    In 15.5 “The Insulation Resistance Test” it gives a table (15.2)which says:-
    “Class 1 heating and cooking equipment with a rating equal to or greater than 3KW = 0.3Mohm”
    “All other Class 1 equipment = 1.0Mohm”
    “Class 2 equipment = 2.0Mohm”

    In note 1 it states “Certain heating and cooking appliances may be unable to meet the insulation resistance requirements, such as where metal sheathed mineral-insulated heating elements are used. It may be necessary in some cases to switch on the appliance for a period of time to drive off absorbed moisture before commencing testing. Additionally the touch current measurement of section 15.6 may be carried out.”

    And finally just to clarify where 0.5Mohm may have come from we go back up the page and find this paragraph “The applied test voltage should be approximately 500VDC. The test instrument should be capable of maintaining this test voltage with a load resistance of 0.5Mohm”

    #348186
    eastlmark
    Moderator

    Re: Pat test failed,What mega reading do i need

    Hollytree_Technical wrote:Just pulled the “Code of Practice for In-Service Inspection and Testing of Electrical Equipment – 3rd edition” off the shelf to check what it says and help to clear up any confusion.
    In 15.5 “The Insulation Resistance Test” it gives a table (15.2)which says:-
    “Class 1 heating and cooking equipment with a rating equal to or greater than 3KW = 0.3Mohm”
    “All other Class 1 equipment = 1.0Mohm”
    “Class 2 equipment = 2.0Mohm”

    In note 1 it states “Certain heating and cooking appliances may be unable to meet the insulation resistance requirements, such as where metal sheathed mineral-insulated heating elements are used. It may be necessary in some cases to switch on the appliance for a period of time to drive off absorbed moisture before commencing testing. Additionally the touch current measurement of section 15.6 may be carried out.”

    And finally just to clarify where 0.5Mohm may have come from we go back up the page and find this paragraph “The applied test voltage should be approximately 500VDC. The test instrument should be capable of maintaining this test voltage with a load resistance of 0.5Mohm”


    good info there but, is a washing machine, as it contains a mineral heater, classed as heating appliance?

    #348187
    garn
    Participant

    Re: Pat test failed,What mega reading do i need

    Procedure & guide Pat Testing

    Classes Of Appliances

    Class 1 Earthed Appliances = No symbol
    Class 2 Double Insulated = ➡ ( http://www.google.co.uk/imgres?imgurl=h … m=1&itbs=1 )

    Visual Inspections

    1 Check For Signs Of Cracks,damage or Heating
    2 Ensure plug Pins are Insulated
    3 check Plug is Correctly Terminated
    4 Check connections are tight
    5 Ensure correct fuse size And that fuse carries Asta symbol :arrow:( http://www.google.co.uk/imgres?imgurl=h … m=1&itbs=1 )
    6Check cable Anchorage is secure

    Fuse Sizes

    1 . IT Equipment = 3 Or 5 Amp
    2 . Motor Powered equipment = 10 Amp
    3 . Heating equipment = 13 Amp

    CABLES

    1 No connector Blocks or Joins
    2 No Lumps hard or soft Spots
    3 No damage to insulation or cuts to cable

    Appliances

    1 No Missing Screws; or cracks or damage to Appliance casing
    2 no signs of Overheating
    3 On/off switch Operates correctly
    4 No excessive contamination to the casing

    Extension leads
    Extension Leads Must be Fitted with A Minimum Of 1.25mm cable and Fitted with an earth cable.


    If Any of The 1st Procedure Above Have Failed There Is No need To carry on With The Other Tests Either put A Failed Sticker On IT Or Record the Information In A Log Or Carry Out A Safe Repair.

    Electrical Tests required

    1 Earth bond Test
    2 insulation Test
    3 Polarity Test
    4 IEC cables To be LABELLED and Tested SEPARATELY

    EARTH BOND TESTS

    ONLY APPLICABLE FOR CLASS 1 APPLIANCES AND 3 CORE LEADS
    ATTACH EARTH BOND CLIP TO APPLIANCE CHASSIS

    MAXIMUM READING
    0.1 Ohms+CABLE RESISTANCE (REFER To Cable resistance Table)
    Earth Bond test Currents

    IT = Equipment = 100 0r 200 MA
    OR
    ALL Other Class 1 appliances
    Up to 1.5Times The rating of The Fuse or A maximum Of 25 Amps.

    [b] Cable Resistance

    Cable csa(mm)………….. ohms Per Metre

    0.5mm =====================0.390 0hms
    0.75mm=====================0.0260 Ohms
    1.0mm======================0.0195 Ohms
    1.25mm=====================0.0156 Ohms
    1.5mm======================0.0133 Ohms
    2.5mm======================0.008 Ohms
    4mm========================0.005 Ohms
    Examples
    A 15m extension cable reel with A cable size of 1.5mm would have an earth bond pass mark of 0.1995 Ohms =( 1.5m x 0.0133 Ohms )

    an appliance fitted with a 7meter 1mm cable would have an earth bond pass mark of = 0.2365 Ohms = (0.1+(7m x0.0195 Ohms

    Insulation and Leakage Tests
    The Insulation And leakage test below are Applicable to all types Of appliances.

    if appliance is IT/ The electronic Insulation Test can be Substituted for the leakage test.

    When testing Class 2 appliances ensure earth Bond Clip Is In contact with the appliance.

    Ensure appliance switches are in the on position where possible.

    Insulation Test

    Minimum Allowable Insulation Test

    Class 1 Heating Appliances = 3kw = 0.3 M Ohms

    Other class 1 Appliances = 1 M Ohms

    Other Class 2 Appliances = 2 M Ohms

    Leakage Tests WARNING POWER ON TEST ENSURE THAT THE APPLIANCE IS IN A SAFE STATE

    MAXIMUM LEAKAGE VALUES

    Portable or hand held Class1======= 0.3m Ohms

    class 1 heating appliances========= 0.75mA or 0.75mA Per KW.max 5mA.

    Other Class 1 appliances ================== 3.5mA

    Class 2======================================0.25mA

    I would Advise Anyone with Limited Knowledge Reading This Thread To go and do a course.
    There May be 1 at your local Tech College twice a year That Could Cost you Around £500.00 or there Are Some Courses Which You May have To Travel And They Are Usually Expensive Plus You will Need Board And Loge For About Theree Days

    Or Do one Online With no Pressure ➡ http://www.google.co.uk/url?sa=t&source … GnNuTtJSIg

    Happy and safe Testing garn… 🙂

    #348188
    spanner51
    Participant

    Re: Pat test failed,What mega reading do i need

    Excellent reading garn

    I found this which might help anyone

    http://www.pat-testing.info/test.htm

    #348189
    simonb
    Participant

    Re: Pat test failed,What mega reading do i need

    Iv had some training with PAT TESTING few years back now, can someone clear up that when checking for insulation 1 clip on earth and 1 clip on LIVE and NEUTRAL, am i correct in assuming SOME timers wont switch in the heater and motor until the machine is in use? thus giving an inaccurate reading?

    i always run with RCD during test incase old style fuse box in property?

    simonb

    #348190
    garn
    Participant

    Re: Pat test failed,What mega reading do i need

    Hi Simonb Its Funny You Should Pull Me On This That’s The only bit That i Left Out I didnt Want To confuse Anyone On That Bit Your On about.

    All I will say hear that you May get a Fail With The Leakage Test Or a Pass Depending On The appliance New Or Old. Iv Unbaged Brand New Ones And They Have Failed The Leak test

    but it has To pass The First 2 Tests.
    RPE====== Ohms
    RISO===== M Ohms
    LEAK===== m A
    You Are On The Correct Track.

    This Is Only A Guide And I would Prefer Anyone Who Is reading This Thread And has Limited Knowledge To Take A Course.
    Its very Easy And Cheap Enough and It Will give Them A Sense Of Confidence Out There The Work Place.

    Garn…
    In Extreme Failures Cut The Flex Off But I can Guarantee That You Will never Hear From The Customer Again 😆

    #348191
    Hollytree_Technical
    Participant

    Re: Pat test failed,What mega reading do i need

    eastlmark wrote:good info there but, is a washing machine, as it contains a mineral heater, classed as heating appliance?

    There is no definitive answer in the book so it is one of those questions where you have to try and interpret the guide as best as you can, the way I tend to look at it is this:

    If there is more than 3KW of heating elements then in theory at least I would be able to class it as a heating appliance and pass it at 0.3Mohm, however in practice I prefer to make 1Mohm my standard pass/fail mark for everything and between 1Mohm and 8Mohm my advisory limits*, I do this because we all know how jittery some control boards can get when an element gets near or below the 1Mohm mark and when combined with the cumulative effects of other appliances it can be enough to knock out some RCDs, it also isn’t that hard to reach most of the time.

    *Advisory limits = a part that looks like it isn’t far from failing and may or may not last a decent time after my visit, customer given choice of having pre-emptive replacement for just the extra cost of part or face possible second call out and parts within a short space of time.

    #348192
    Martin
    Participant

    Re: Pat test failed,What mega reading do i need

    pmb wrote:Letting agent has asked me to look at a washing machine and dryer at the same property, Both failed PAT test,
    Whats the minimum I need to get on the mega, Is it 2 meg now.

    After all this tech info flying about, Class 1 & 2 appliances, mineral heaters and such, I wonder how the OP (pmb) is getting on and what the test results showed to that letting agent on the failed appliances? His 2 meg findings may have been sufficient for the PAT tester to issue a fail certificate, and rightly so in my book. 🙂

Viewing 12 posts - 1 through 12 (of 12 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.